Great question @DannyPancratz - I think I know how this works but let me double-check and get back to you to be absolutely sure. :)
Ok, my hunch was correct. Confirmed with our engineers. So when you move content into a category that has this setting enabled, it will impact the various counters we have for topics, replies, answers and likes. However, it won’t impact points that have already been earned. Once you have earned points, they are no longer linked to the original activities. One thing that could happen is a step down in rank - that is, if a rank depends on topics, replies, answers and likes and this change gets a user below a certain threshold - but only once you rebuild the ranks.
By the way, I’m also creating a new archive section for this community at the moment. My intention is to keep this setting disabled so that user statistics aren’t impacted at all.
Thanks, @Kenneth R. That makes sense on the counters.
I’m glad that the points are not disrupted.